Most of us grow up with a version of history that feels tidy. It has villains and heroes, beginnings and endings, and above all, it has progress. We’re told things used to be worse, but over time they got better, and now we live at the end of that story. But when you spend time with writers who dig deeper into the past, the neatness disappears. The story becomes jagged, unpredictable, and often uncomfortable. That’s what happened when I read Raymond Ibrahim. His work isn’t about polishing history into something easy to digest. It’s about showing how messy it really was, and how much of that mess we’ve conveniently forgotten.
What struck me most was how relevant it all felt. These weren’t just tales of long-dead empires or obscure battles. They were lessons about human nature, about how civilizations rise and fall, about the patterns that keep repeating because we never bother to remember them. Reading Ibrahim was like suddenly realizing the ground you’re standing on isn’t as solid as you thought. The past isn’t safely behind us. It’s still with us, shaping the present.
Out of everything I read, a set of lessons emerged…
Reminder: The Western Spirit is a reader-supported publication. We are very close to 100 paid subscribers!
If you’ve been enjoying these essays, consider becoming a paid subscriber. For a few dollars a month, you’ll get:
In-depth pieces on forgotten battles, brave men, and turning points in Western history
Reflections on faith, order, tradition, and the deeper meaning behind culture
Full access to the growing archive — essays, book breakdowns, and historical deep dives
This project exists because readers like you make it possible.
Lesson 1: History Isn’t Neutral
The first surprise is how slanted history is. You assume it’s a record of facts, but the facts are curated. Entire centuries of conflict can be ignored, while minor episodes are magnified. Think of the millions of Europeans carried off into slavery in North Africa. For the people who lived then, it was constant, inescapable. But for us, it barely exists in memory. That silence isn’t accidental. It comes from the choices of people who wrote the textbooks, people who decided what parts of the past were useful to remember.
Once you realize history isn’t neutral, you start to question what you were taught. Why do we hear endlessly about some atrocities but nothing about others? Why do we treat certain groups as eternal victims and others as eternal villains?
Lesson 2: Memory Is Survival
A civilization that remembers survives. One that forgets is eaten alive. That pattern repeats again and again. The groups that carried their history in memory were harder to deceive or surprise. They had seen the tactics before, and they knew the stakes. The groups that forgot treated every threat as if it were something new, something extraordinary, when in fact it was only the latest turn of a very old wheel.
It’s not just about remembering dates and battles. It’s about remembering what people are capable of, both good and bad. Forgetfulness leads to naïveté, and naïveté is expensive. If your ancestors lived with the constant reality of raids and slavery, and you forget it, you’ll be baffled when similar forces appear again. You’ll treat them as accidents instead of patterns. Memory is not nostalgia. It’s a shield. Without it, you’re defenseless.
Lesson 3: Violence Was Normal
Modern life makes violence look like an exception, a breakdown of the natural order. But for most of history, violence was the natural order. It was as normal as taxes. Coastal towns built watchtowers not for scenery but to spot raiders. Families expected that their sons might be carried off. Kings budgeted for ransom as if it were just another expense.
This is hard for us to grasp because we live in a pocket of peace. We think it’s the default state of human life. It isn’t. The default state is conflict, with brief interruptions of peace. Realizing that shifts your perspective. Instead of treating peace as permanent, you start to see it as fragile. And once you see it that way, you treat it more carefully. You prepare for the day it might vanish, because history suggests it always does.
Lesson 4: Slavery Was Universal
When we talk about slavery today, it’s usually through the narrow lens of the transatlantic trade. That’s important, but it’s not the whole story. For centuries, the Mediterranean was a vast market for human beings. Europeans were captured and sold in North Africa, Africans were taken by Arabs and Ottomans. It was a universal institution.
Recognizing that doesn’t excuse anyone. What it does is level the moral field. It reminds us that slavery wasn’t the unique sin of one group but the temptation of all humanity. Given power, most societies used it to exploit others. That truth cuts against the modern narrative, but it also brings clarity. We’re not dealing with a story of good versus evil but with the reality of human weakness. And once you see it that way, you stop being surprised by it.
Lesson 5: Cowardice Costs More Than Courage
Compromise looks smart in the short term. Pay the tribute, sign the treaty, look the other way. For leaders facing pressure, it buys peace today. But over and over, history shows that cowardice only raises the price tomorrow. The tribute never satisfied. It only signaled weakness, and weakness invited more demands.
By contrast, courage was expensive but often cheaper in the long run. The cities and leaders who resisted, even when outnumbered, sometimes fell. But sometimes they survived precisely because they refused to yield. Courage didn’t always guarantee victory, but cowardice almost always guaranteed defeat. That’s a harsh truth, but it explains why some civilizations endured while others vanished. Fear is understandable, but history punishes it without mercy.
Lesson 6: Truth Offends
One of the strangest experiences of reading about the past is realizing how angry people get when you tell it plainly. Facts are offensive when they cut across the stories people prefer. Even if the record is clear, people resist. They call it bias, exaggeration, or hate. But what they really mean is that it makes them uncomfortable.
That’s a lesson in itself. Telling the truth will often cost you. It won’t win applause. But if the truth matters more than comfort, you have to risk it. History doesn’t care about your feelings. It happened. The only question is whether you’re willing to see it as it was.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to The Western Spirit to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.